Beyond the Scoreboard
The APL Draft: Big Names, Little Transparency

Two of the five teams have no owner, the captains were swapped hours before the draft, and serving national players went home without a contract. The Afghanistan Cricket Board has yet to explain any of it.
When talk of the Afghanistan Premier League coming back first came out and some time had passed, things were good: three franchises had been sold, Kabul, Balkh and Kandahar. In October, the board’s chief executive, Naseeb Khan, said the remaining two deals would be done as soon as possible.
Today Kabul, Kandahar and Nangarhar have owners. Balkh and Paktia do not. Balkh’s owner has pulled out, and Paktia has never been sold. Momand says Naseeb Khan has now acknowledged the Balkh withdrawal, and that the news was kept quiet until the final moments of the draft.
That means two of the five squads picked in Dubai belong to nobody. Players were drafted into them. Someone has to pay those players, and the board has not yet said who.
One of our capable sports journalists, Ibrahim Momand, believes the league should never have been opened in this state. Hamid Shinwari, the cricket board’s former chief executive, also wrote this on his Facebook page after the first ceremonies of the league’s relaunch, and I myself hold the same position as both of them: things are this tense, yet players are still being asked to sign contracts, and sponsors and broadcasters are being asked to trust a timetable, while two teams still have no buyer. At the end of the day, the cricket board will be forced to take this money out of the nation’s purse.
The swap
A week earlier, at the leaders’ draft, the international mentors chose their captains, even though they had very little real choice. Mark Boucher’s Nangarhar took Rahmanullah Gurbaz and Paktia took Rahmat Shah. Shortly before the player draft began, the two captains changed places.
Momand writes that Boucher told reporters he found out “as a guest”, like everyone else, and had no part in the decision. This means the leaders’ draft decided nothing, and the real decisions are made behind the curtain, behind closed doors.
Ibrahim Momand offers two guesses, both about personal friction between the captain and the franchise’s management. But some sources also say that Gurbaz moved himself to the Paktia team because he could not bring his friends together at Nangarhar. Nobody at the board has explained the change, and when nobody explains, people guess.
Categories that did not hold
Another important issue was the player categories. Players are drafted in five categories, and the category sets the pay. Each franchise works under a salary cap of 725,000 US dollars.
At yesterday’s draft, the categories were not respected at all. Players registered as Diamond, worth 80,000 dollars, were signed in Gold for 40,000. The top categories were filled with players the franchises could not turn down but who are not at the level of international T20 cricket.
If a player registered at one price and was signed for half of it, he has the right to know why, and who made that decision.
Who was left out
TOLOnews has published a list of twenty Afghan players who were not picked at yesterday’s draft. They include capable T20 players such as Najibullah Zadran, Shahidullah Kamal, Riaz Hassan, Wafiullah Tarakhil, Samiullah Sarmast and Arab Gul Momand, who perform well in domestic T20 cricket. Najibullah Zadran, one of the most experienced batters in the country, asked on Facebook how players who are not good enough for the APL can be good enough to play for Afghanistan. Tarakhil also complained, writing on his Facebook page that this is not the Afghanistan Premier League but a “friendship” league.
In the view of Afghan fans and cricket experts, they wanted to see players like the fast bowler Aman Kunari, Faheem Khewawal, Aimal Shaheen and Younis Zadran in the APL. If our own league does not show players like these to the world, who will?
According to some reports, some UAE-based players were invited to the draft venue so they could talk to coaches and captains face to face, and from this the concern can arise that friendship, regional loyalty and family ties decided many of the picks in this year’s draft.
Being fair
Ninety places from a pool of 462 means most players were always going home disappointed. No league can find room for every player, or for every fan’s favourite. But the right must go to the one who has earned it, not that old players like Hashmatullah Shahidi are taken into a team on the basis of friendship, while Wafiullah Tarakhil, who has no connections, is left as a name on paper.
Yesterday I read a post by Ibrahim Momand in which he made some very good proposals, and his proposals are practical. Coaches who already have jobs with the board should not hold another role in the league. The franchises should hire their own staff, under proper oversight, so that new people can also find a way into Afghan cricket. National selection should move away from the turn system, so that no player expects a place everywhere just because he once had his turn in the national team. And owners and captains should pick the best players available.
The board can also do something itself: publish everything. The full pool, the categories, the prices and all the squads, and present the nation and the world with proof of its own clean hands. If it does not, it means, as the Pashto saying goes, that water is running under the straw.
In the end, several very basic points still remain unclear. Before the first match on 27 December, the board must answer three questions. Who will own Balkh and Paktia, and who pays their players until then? Who decided to swap the Nangarhar and Paktia captains, and why? Was any player signed below his registered category, and on whose word?
ASJF NEWS invites the Afghanistan Cricket Board and the five franchises to respond, and will publish any reply. The views in this column are the author’s own.
